Whether it’s for a birthday, the upcoming holidays, or just a moment worth celebrating, it’s always worth getting a custom-made cake. We asked our readers for their favorite spots for custom cakes in and around Jersey City, and they did not disappoint! Here are some of the most recommended spots and all other great businesses that were sent in.

Highly Recommended

Carmen Rosa’s Bakery
37 Coles St, Jersey City

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Carmen Rosa's Bakery (@crb_cakes)

Carmen Rosa’s Bakery offers traditional Dominican cakes and custom desserts. They recommend sending cake orders at least 3-4 weeks in advance. Call or stop by for orders.

Website: https://www.carmenrosasbakery.com/

Jam Cakery
326 5th St, Jersey City

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Jam Cakery Events (@jamcakeryevents)

Jam Cakery offers custom plant-based cakes as well as full-service catering. All cakes are vegan and prices start at $45 with several flavors available including Red Velvet, Chocolate Fudge, Vanilla, Pink Champagne, Espresso, and more.

Website: https://www.jamcakeryevents.com/

Dulce de Leche Bakery
376 Central Ave, Jersey City
6510 Bergenline Ave, West New York
55 West Palisade Ave, Englewood

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Dulce De Leche Bakery (@dulcedelechebakery)

Dulce de Leche will be accepting custom cake orders again starting November 5. Custom cakes start at $6 per serving and they require a minimum of 3-4 weeks notice for all orders.

Website: https://www.dulcedelechebakery.com/

Torico
20 Erie St, Jersey City

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Torico Ice Cream (@toricoicecream)

Torico offers custom ice cream cakes that serves anywhere from 4 to 25 guests. Cakes can be ordered for pickup online or in store, and they even offer seasonal cakes to try like this month’s Pumpkin Patch Cake.

Website: https://www.toricoicecream.com/

Sweet
343 Garden St, Hoboken

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Sweet Hoboken (@sweethoboken)

Sweet is a Hoboken bakery offering custom cupcakes and cakes. Cake orders should be placed at least a week in advance and flavor options include Red Velvet, Mocha, Carrot, Raspberry, and plenty more.

Website: http://sweethoboken.com/

More Recommendations

Double Batch Bakery
1102 Avenue C, Bayonne

Website/Social: https://www.doublebatchbakery.com/

T Marie Bakes

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/tmarie_bakes/

Dahlia’s Ice Cream Spot
290 Central Ave, Jersey City

Website/Social: https://www.facebook.com/Dahlias-Ice-Cream-Spot-324336330970636/

Cocoa Bakery
275 Grand St, Jersey City
475 Central Ave, Jersey City

Website/Social: https://cocoabakerycafe.com/

Belle.Cakes.Cookies

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/Belle.Cakes.Cookies/

Baking Mama
88 Hudson St, Hoboken

Website/Social: https://www.bakingmama.com/

Bread and Spoon

Website/Social: https://www.breadandspoon.com/

Sweet and Flour
300 Front St, Secaucus

Website/Social: http://www.sweetandflournj.com/

Porter Provisions
1100 Ave at Port Imperial, Weehawken

Website/Social: https://www.porterportimperial.com/porter-provisions/

Bovella’s
1085 Route 22 East, Mountainside
101 E Broad St, Westfield

Website/Social: https://www.bovellas.com/

Splurge Bakery
105 Main St, Millburn

Website/Social: https://www.splurgebakery.com/

Cupcakes by Nicolle

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/cupcakes_by_nicolle/

Carla Reinoso

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/mamasucre28/

Beenie’s
38 Morris St, Morristown

Website/Social: https://www.beeniesicecream.com/cakes

Slices of Happiness

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/slicesofhappinesss/

Kedby Kay Cakes

Website/Social: http://www.kedbykay.com/

Hudson Cakery
1816 Willow Ave, Weehawken

Website/Social: https://hudsoncakery.com/

Whisked Confections
136 S Valley Rd, West Orange

Website/Social: https://www.whiskedconfections.com/

Epic Cake NYC

Website/Social: https://www.facebook.com/epiccakenyc

Desserts by Amanda

Website/Social: https://www.facebook.com/DessertsByAmanda/

Calandras
204 1st Ave, Newark

Website/Social: https://calandrasbakery.com/

Foodi Tuti

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/foodituti/

Carlo’s Bakery
95 Washington St, Hoboken

Website/Social: https://www.carlosbakery.com/

Derry Delights

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/derrydelights/

Baked with Sweetness

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/bakedwithsweetness/

City and Shore Bakery

Website/Social: https://www.cityandshorebakery.com/

Yaris Cakes

Website/Social: https://www.instagram.com/yariscakes/

byPensa
214 Humboldt St, Brooklyn

Website/Social: https://www.bypensa.com/